120 Years of Bayer – And Then This: When the Newcomer Crashes the Party

"Punkte verschenkt" – that's a feeling every Bayer fan knows all too well. You're up 2-0 after eight minutes, the celebration for the 120th anniversary is in full swing, and yet you only walk away with a point. Against Holstein Kiel. A newly promoted team. At home. In the sold-out BayArena, where the atmosphere was supposed to be jubilant. But somehow, there was that familiar sinking feeling in the pit of every Leverkusen fan's stomach: the tendency to turn sure victories into nail-biters.

Those first few minutes were perfect. Boniface and Hofmann both found the net, and Palacios – the Argentinian maestro celebrating his birthday – orchestrated both goals. 2-0, and it all looked like a relaxed afternoon, another routine win for Xabi Alonso in his 100th game as Bayer's manager. But instead of killing off Kiel, we let them back into the game. Why? Well, that’s what we’re all wondering. "Unfocused," Hradecky said. "Not smart enough," Alonso added. Whatever it was, it felt like someone flipped a switch – the wrong one, unfortunately.

Then, just before halftime, that goal came. Geschwill headed in after a corner – a typical Bayer goal to concede, if we're being honest. Set-piece goals have plagued this team for years. And what did Kiel do? They fought back. Not with dazzling play, but with persistence. Kiel fought, you have to give them that. But it wasn’t like they were outplaying us. It was Bayer 04 making things hard for themselves. There were plenty of chances, but the third goal never came. And then there was that penalty. Frimpong brought Gigovic down, Arp converted with ease. Suddenly, it was 2-2, and we fans were left wondering: "This can't be happening, can it?" But it did. Again.

The bitter part of this draw isn't just the dropped points. It was supposed to be a day of celebration: 120 years of Bayer 04, Xabi's 100th match, a packed stadium – and yet, in the end, we're left with a sour taste. Not because Kiel was so strong, but because we weakened ourselves. Hradecky called it "giving away points," and that’s spot on. You have to ask why, after such a dominant start, we stopped playing football. Why let the opponent back in instead of putting the game to bed?

Of course, there were positives: Palacios’ strong return to the starting eleven, Boniface scoring again, and the fact that this team is technically operating at a very high level. But that alone isn’t enough to win games like these. It takes more – consistency, cleverness, a little more ruthlessness perhaps. Because if you want to compete for the title, or at least stay near the top, you can't let games like this slip away.

And so we fans are left with mixed feelings once again. On the one hand, we know how good this team can be. On the other hand, we know how they can sometimes get in their own way. Sure, now there's the international break, followed by Eintracht Frankfurt at home. And maybe this little pause will help clear our heads. But one thing is certain: if Bayer 04 truly wants to compete at the top this season, they need to learn how to close out these kinds of games.